SPJA vs. Cy 2009 Anime Awards
Category 01: Best Voice Actor (Japanese)
SPJA Pick: Kappei Yamaguchi - DEATH NOTE - L
My Pick: Fukuyama Jun - CODE GEASS – Lelouch
Lulu is a really tough character to play (a very wide range of emotions, plus a great deal of attention has to be paid to nuance for this extremely duplicitous character~). But really also b/c he’s got such a range of talents; if you’ve heard him in Okane ga Nai, you wouldn’t believe it’s the same person who plays that scoffing, deep-voiced Lelouch!
Category 02: Best Voice Actor (English)
SPJA Pick: Kyle Hebert - GURREN LAGANN - Kamina
My Pick: Johnny Yong Bosch - CODE GEASS – Lelouch
He truly beautifully navigates the many faces of Lelouch through the whole series and then REALLY lets it out for the exhilaratingly dramatic final few eps.
Category 03: Best Voice Actress (Japanese)
SPJA Pick: Junko Takeuchi - NARUTO - Naruto Uzumaki
My Pick: Junko Takeuchi - NARUTO - Naruto Uzumaki
Sure, why not? Always great in this role that demands both comedic and dramatic extremes. Her efforts to make her voice deeper to portray a 5-year-old Naruto are pretty impressive too!
Category 04: Best Voice Actress (English)
SPJA Pick: Michelle Ruff - BLEACH THE MOVIE: MoN - Rukia Kuchiki
My Pick: Laura Bailey - KODOCHA – Sana
This woman has deserved an award for YEARS. Her comic role as Sana is just unbelievable. She completely commits to this crazy role and is a major reason why this series is as funny as it is!
Category 05: Best Casting Director
SPJA Pick: Jaime Simone - BLEACH
My Pick: Kevin Seymour – CODE GEASS
Again, I’ve gotta go with Code Geass. Johnny Yong Bosch as Lelouch alone is worth the award’s weight in gold, but toss Yuri Lowenthal in there as the serious and sweet shounen hero Suzaku, velvety-voiced Mary Elizabeth McGlynn as Cornelia and Liam O’Brien as the amicably insane Professor Lloyd (boldest break from the Japanese voice cast, and it REALLY worked!) and you’ve got some really smart casting decisions that made this dub shine!!
Category 06: Best Character Design
SPJA Pick: Masaru Kitao of Madhouse - DEATH NOTE
My Pick: Masaru Kitao of Madhouse - DEATH NOTE
Yeah, very good adaptation of Obata Takeshi’s gorgeous manga art, especially with the Shinigamis. But adapting Code Geass’s huge and varied cast and intricate CLAMP clothing designs is pretty admirable too—they deserve an honorable mention at least.
Category 07: Best Mechanical Design
SPJA Pick: Yoh Yoshirari - GURREN LAGANN
My Pick: Sunrise - CODE GEASS
Oh, come ON! You can’t not give this award to Sunrise, the masters of mecha! The gorgeous Knights of the Round mechas are varied/easily identifiable and beautiful without excessive embellishment or tacky add-ons like colored sunglasses (sorry, Gurren Lagann :P).
Category 08: Best Male Character
SJPA Pick: L – DEATH NOTE
My Pick: Lelouch - CODE GEASS
L’s a great, quirky character, but his personality is fairly 1-dimensional and his actions are not driven by any particularly admirable or powerful motive. Lelouch is often compared to Light (both being extremely Machiavellian), but what distinguishes him above Light is that despite his increasing corruption like Light, he doesn’t become all-bad—there is still sincere tenderness in his heart for his loved ones but without the excessive sentimentality that has made past Gundam, etc, heroes a little unbelievable. Lelouch is a very intelligent and manipulative young man who’s done both extremely horrible and extremely noble things—truly multi-faceted and much more realistic, fascinating and original than most every other anime character in existence. The fact that he still manages to maintain mass appeal as the lead of a Sunrise series is a testament to how round and well-crafted a character he is.
Category 09: Best Female Character
SPJA Pick: Rukia Kuchiki - BLEACH THE MOVIE: MEMORIES OF NOBODY
My Pick: Rukia Kuchiki - BLEACH THE MOVIE: MEMORIES OF NOBODY
Sure, why not? I haven’t seen this movie or much of Bleach, but I won’t argue; no major series portrays women in a more positive, empowering and respectful light than Bleach, and Rukia is Bleach’s leading lady, so it seems fair. I do think Code Geass had some pretty impressive women too, though—most notably C.C and Kallen (who actually BEATS our precious male superhero Suzaku in the final showdown! How’s that for woman power? ^^)
Category 10: Best Mascot Character
SPJA Pick: Mokona - xxxHOLIC
My Pick: Mokona - TSUBASA
Can’t argue with Mokona! :D The non-speaking Mokona that first appeared back in Magic Knight Rayearth was already so friggin’ cute he caused instantaneous fits of fangirl squee, but the new cuter-and-smaller, speech-enabled Mokonas that grace xxHOLIC and Tsubasa are even cuter! SPJA chose the black Mokona from xxxHOLIC but I personally think the white one from Tsubasa shows a lot more humor and personality (perhaps just because he interacts more with the main characters). However, White Mokona shows an added layer of depth beyond cutesy mindlessness when we see him face the really difficult events that split the TRC party up in the latter half of the series. Also, Tsubasa’s Mokona is the genius originator of the “Mokona Impersonation Technique” which has allowed him to do hilarious things like refer to Fai as “wife” in Kurogane’s voice. That alone makes him more deserving. :P
Category 11: Best Backround Design
SPJA Pick: Minoru Nakamura of Studio Pierrot - BLEACH
My Pick: Production I.G. – Seirei no Moribito
Seriously, we’re talking Studio Ghibli-level gorgeous natural landscapes of pre-modern Japan—in a TV SERIES!! How could Moribito not win??
Category 12: Best Original Video Animation
SPJA Pick: LUCKY STAR OVA - Bandai Entertainment
My Pick: Saint Seiya Hades-Sanctuary Arc - not licensed
All StS fans agree, the incredible new animation/CG in this OVA really brings the epic glamour of the legendary old manga to true life. The new seiyuu and animators’ reverent treatment of this classic both brings it up-to-date with modern sensibilities while respecting the hallmarks that made it a classic back in the early 90’s.
Category 13: Best Feature Film
SPJA Pick: The Girl Who Leapt Through Time – Bandai Entertainment
My Pick: Sword of the Stranger - Bandai Entertainment
From all I’ve heard of it, GWLTT is probably the rightful winner of this category, but I haven’t seen it so I can’t say. ^^; What I have seen that has really, REALLY impressed me is this little known gem called “Sword of the Stranger.” It’s a samurai period piece with truly the most breathtaking and realistic-looking animated sword fight I’ve ever seen. Those animators are GODS, I tell you!! Though the story doesn’t break any new ground, the execution of every last moment is flawless and even if there’s nothing particularly amazing about the story, something about it lingers like you wouldn’t believe. There are moments that replayed in my head again and again for the two weeks after I first saw this film and though you barely get enough time with the very appealing characters in this 1.5 hour movie, they’re so round and believable that you could imagine what the rest of their lives have been like and would really like to see them more. It’s really a shame this is just a one-shot movie rather than a series. The nameless samurai hero really has the potential to become a timeless and widely beloved character.
Category 14: Best Television Series
SPJA Pick: GURREN LAGANN - Bandai Entertainment
My Pick: DEATH NOTE – FUNimation
You thought I was going to choose Code Geass, didn’t you? :) I was sorely tempted, but Death Note is such an achievement not only in direction, storytelling, style and artwork, but such a breath of fresh air in the often trope and fan service-filled anime world that it really deserves the honor. CG is incredible, don’t get me wrong, and the absolute epitome of the Sunrise/Gundam epic genre, but Death Note is something we haven’t seen before, and the fact that it achieved mass appeal despite its darker, completely un-cutesy tone and story is a true marvel.
Category 15: Best Original Score
SPJA Pick: DEATH NOTE - Yoshihisa Hirano and Hideki Taniuchi
My Pick: TSUBASA – Yuki Kajiura
A true legend in the anime industry, her reputation is well-deserved. When she first started out in the .hack era, people were struck by her striking use of vibrant tribal chants over catchy electronic beats. For a time, it seemed her style was very stuck in that mold, but over the years, she’s really broken out to show her mastery over a huge range of genres, including the classical orchestral scores and pop ballads that are more commonly found in anime OSTs—all with her own twist. In Tsubasa, she showcases her amazing range while keeping every piece fresh and soaked in her own striking Yuki Kajiura flavor. I have to give an honorable mention to Code Geass, though—Hitomi Kuroishi’s gorgeous new age vocals really added a different flavor and solemnity (or refreshing feel) to the soundtrack.
I do like that unbelievably bombastic “next episode preview” theme from Death Note though. Talk about drama! :D
Category 16: Best Original Song
SPJA Pick: "Tonight, Tonight, Tonight" - Bleach - Beat Crusaders
My Pick: “Monochrome Kiss” – Kuroshitsuji - SID
I haven’t seen the Bleach OP here, but really, what more could you want from the riveting Kuroshitsuji OP “Monochrome Kiss?” It’s a great song with wonderfully mysterious, mood-setting lyrics and the accompanying animation just immediately throws you into that Victorian gothic/elegant atmosphere that is so characteristic of an essential to this series. You get many beautiful images from this OP, both from the visually and lyrically, and I love that the production people have taken the opportunity to integrate small, intriguingly mysterious “clues” of how the series will end in this opening.
Randomly, if this were the “greatest opening song of all time,” I’d have to go with Soukyuu no Fafner’s “Shangri-La,” hands down. :)
Category 17: Best Director (Japanese)
SPJA Pick: Tetsuro Araki - DEATH NOTE
My Pick: Tetsuro Araki - DEATH NOTE
Hmm, tough one to argue with. Death Note really was beautiful executed throughout (honestly, who thought an anime about a guy writing down names in a notebook could look as action-packed as it does in the anime series?). The few liberties the director took that broke away from the manga’s portrayals were all really excellent additions that enhanced the mood and story. So yeah, Araki-san gets my vote too. :)
Category 18: Best Director (American)
SPJA Pick: Karl Willems - DEATH NOTE
My Pick: Kevin Seymour – CODE GEASS
Hmm, not sure what the English adaptation director does besides voice direction. In that case, I actually think Code Geass’s director deserves this award because the CG characters are much harder to understand for a foreign audience and the subtleties of the unspoken relationships, etc, that the Japanese version puts in for fans’ enjoyment are pretty well preserved in the English version. Or maybe it’s just that Johnny Yong Bosch is such a good actor he hits those nuances w/o any direction. I dunno.
Category 19: Best Manga – Action
SPJA Pick: TSUBASA: RESERVOIR CHRONICLE - Del Rey Manga - CLAMP
My Pick: TSUBASA: RESERVOIR CHRONICLE - Del Rey Manga - CLAMP
I heartily agree with this one. No one does action + dramatic story AND comedy all balanced together like CLAMP. Plus, in what other action manga do you get samurai swordplay, martial arts, hover craft races, fights with giant beasts and magical duels all in the same series? Go, Tsubasa, go!
Category 20: Best Manga - Comedy
SPJA Pick: FAIRY TAIL - Del Rey Manga - Hiro Mashima
My Pick: OURAN HIGH SCHOOL HOST CLUB – Viz – Bisco Hatori
Haven’t read FAIRY TAIL but I doubt any manga in this world is funnier than Ouran High School Host Club (with the possible exception of Slam Dunk, but it’s too close to call and SD is too old to qualify for these awards anyway). I didn’t think it possible, but the manga is actually funnier than the anime. And it’s so hilarious that it apparently has successfully crossed over to the male market too! (yes, despite how heavily girl-catered it is, I’ve seen fanboys purchase and read Host Club too! That’s a testimonial if ever I heard one!)
Category 21: Best Manga - Drama
SPJA Pick: MONSTER - Viz Media - Naoki Urasawa
My Pick: ?
Haven’t read MONSTER but I hear only good things about it, and since I don’t have a strong candidate in mind anyway, I’ll leave it be.
Category 22: Best Publication
SPJA Pick: Shonen Jump - Viz Media
My Pick: ?
Again, I don’t read any anime-related mags so I have no other candidate in mind. SJ it is.
Category 23: Best Full Motion Video in Video Game
SPJA PICK: FINAL FANTASY IV - Square Enix
My Pick: FINAL FANTASY VII: CRISS CORE – Square-Enix
Well, duh—of course something Square-Enix! Oh, but why did they pick FFIV?? Well done, Cecil, but does IV’s new CG really trump something like FFXII or Crisis Core??? Have you SEEN that final scene of Zack’s death? Even the mean, anti-bishounen male gamers cried!
And that's the last of them. What would you guys pick for this year's best of the industry?


